No Place for Abortion in African Traditional Life - Some Reflections
There is no place for abortion even in pre-Christianity African tradition.
2 August, 2002
Reproduced with permission
Note: News of the
problems in South African hospitals reached a Catholic priest
studying for a degree in sacred theology at St. Paul's University in
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. At the time of writing, Father Bonaventure
Turyomumazima of Uganda was preparing a doctoral dissertation on the
relationship between traditional African healing practices, western
medicine and religious belief. While some of his reflections on the
situation are from a Christian perspective, in the paper below he
explains why participation in abortion would prove to be a morally and
culturally traumatic experience for many Africans, regardless of
religious belief.
-Administrator-
Fr. Bonaventure Turyomumazima
*
Introduction
First of all, I want to begin by emphasizing
that those doctors and their collaborators who assist in the termination
of pregnancies have no justification whatsoever. Two areas are clear: that
every human person has the right to life, is clear from the Human Rights
Declaration. In addition, Holy Scripture, and Church Tradition have always
emphasized the sacredness of life, and the dignity of each and every human
being. Hence, from the point of view of Christianity, and the Church's
stand, abortion must be condemned in the strongest terms possible. No one,
has the right to put an end to human life, although the loss of life may
be allowed, but only in extraordinary circumstances.
I wish, however, to approach the rest of the reflections from the point of
view of what I may call pre-Christianity African religious beliefs and
practices on the subject of abortion. My stand is that there is no place
for abortion even in pre-Christianity African tradition. Here is why:
1- African Society's Love for Children
It is popularly known, and almost taken for granted, that in traditional
Africa, even before the coming of Christianity, children were highly
valued in society. This does not mean that there were no situations of
abuse; there were cases where children were mistreated and neglected. The
worst is in reference to the birth of twins. "The birth of twins and
triplets is an event out of the ordinary. Therefore, in many African
societies twins and triplets are treated with fear or special care.
Formerly, some societies used to kill such children; others killed both
the mother and the children. This, however, was not the universal
practice, for other societies greeted the birth of twins with great joy
and satisfaction, as a sign of rich fertility." (MBITI, J. S., African
Religions and Philosophy, p. 117; see MAGESA, L., African Religion: the Moral
Traditions of Abundant Life, pp.
146-148).). All in all, the fact is that children were, and are still,
seen as precious.
2- Marriage and Procreation
We must note that marriage and procreation in African communities are a
unity: without procreation marriage is incomplete. ((MBITI, J. S.,
African Religions and Philosophy, p. 133). Pregnancy is the first
indication that a new member is on the way. The expectant mother becomes,
therefore, a special person and receives special treatment from her
neighbors and relatives. This special treatment starts before and
continues after child-birth. In some African societies, marriage is not
fully consummated until the wife has given birth. For this reason, there
is general abhorrence of barrenness in most African societies. "Unhappy is
the woman who fails to get children for, whatever other qualities she
might possess, her failure to bear children is worse than committing
genocide: she has become the dead end of human life, not only for the
genealogical line but also for herself"(MBITI, J. S., African Religions
and Philosophy, p. 110)
3- Children as Survival of Race and
Assurance of Personal Immortality.
As we indicated above, when a woman that has not given birth to a child
dies, in the eyes of African society there will be nobody of her own
immediate blood to 'remember' her, to keep her in the state of personal
immortality: she will simply be 'forgotten'. (MBITI, J. S., African
Religions and Philosophy, p. 110). Therefore, a child not only
continues the physical line of life, in some societies thought to be a
re-incarnation of the departed, but becomes the intensely religious focus
of keeping the parents in their state of personal immortality. (MBITI, J.
S., African Religions and Philosophy, p. 120) A person who,
therefore, has no descendants in effect quenches the fire of life, and
becomes forever dead since his line of physical continuation is blocked if
he does not get married and bear children. This is a sacred understanding
and obligation which must neither be abused nor despised. (MBITI, J. S.,
African Religions and Philosophy, p. 133).
4- Polygamy as Search for Children
Getting married to two or more wives is a custom found all over Africa,
though in some societies it is less common than in others. The custom fits
well into the social structure of traditional life, and into the thinking
of the people, serving many useful purposes, one of which is the search
for children. If the philosophical or theological attitude towards
marriage and procreation is that these are an aid towards the partial
recapture or attainment of the lost immortality (that is after the
withdrawal of God to the heavens - a kind of 'Fall' of man), the more
wives a man has the more children he is likely to have, and the more
children the stronger the power of 'immortality' in the family. He who has
many descendants has the strongest possible manifestation of
'immortality', he is 'reborn' in the multitude of his descendants, and
there are many who 'remember' him after he has died physically and entered
his 'personal immortality'. Such a man has the attitude that 'the more
we are, the bigger I am'. Children are the glory of marriage,
and the more there are of them the greater the glory. (MBITI, J. S.,
African Religions and Philosophy, p. 142, cfr. p. 98)
5- Communal Responsibility over Children's
Well-being.
The birth of a child is, moreover, the concern not only of the parents but
of many relatives, including the living and the departed. For it is the
community which must protect the child, feed it, bring it up, educate it,
and in many other ways incorporate it into the wider community. The child
cannot be exclusively 'my child' but only 'our child'. "Children are the
buds of society, and every birth is the arrival of 'spring' when life
shoots out and the community thrives," writes Professor John S. Mbiti (MBITI,
J. S., African Religions and Philosophy, p.110; see also MAGESA,
L., African Religion: the Moral Traditions of Abundant Life, p.
83). In this kind of setup, there are no children left abandoned. Even
those children born out of wedlock, have a place in society; many a family
are willing to welcome such children and look after them.
6- Taboos and Rituals for the Preservation
of the Children's Life
In the background of wanting to have as many children as possible,
perhaps, lies the desire to save some, especially in the face of rampant
infant mortality. Because of many sicknesses, and due to lack of proper
medical facilities, a lot of families lost children in their earliest
years of infancy. By producing many children, therefore, a family would
save at least three or four, out of a family of ten. And in order to
preserve the life of a baby, many taboos and rituals surround the whole
period from conception to the birth of the new baby. For instance,
according to the African mentality, "If conception is an occasion of joy,
a good, uncomplicated birth of a healthy child is much more so as it
validates the relationships [existing between the parents, the nearest of
kin, the ancestors and God Himself]. It is a sign of tranquility in the
universe, the pleasure of the ancestors, the good moral standing of the
parents, and a sigh of the defeat of bad people or malevolent spirits by
the protection of the ancestors" (MAGESA, L., African Religion: the
Moral Traditions of Abundant Life, p. 84). For that matter, the
parents must observe strict discipline, during the period when the mother
is expecting; and they must be in good moral standing if the birth is to
take place smoothly...Both parents must be faithful to each other during
the entire pregnancy. "Unfaithfulness of one or the other spouse, or an
incestuous relationship, is sure to result in a difficult delivery,
stillbirth, birth of an abnormal child, or death of the child before it
has been "taken out" and formally named" (MAGESA, L., African Religion:
the Moral Traditions of Abundant Life, p. 85). With reference to the
people of western Kenya, Gunter Wagner explains that "A miscarriage which
occurs suddenly and without causing much pain to the woman is regarded as
the consequence of an act of adultery committed by the wife during her
pregnancy... Suspicions of adultery are also raised if parturition occurs
too soon (after seven or eight months) or if the child is stillborn" (
WAGNER, G., The Bantu of Western Kenya: With Special Reference to the
Vugusu and Logoli. Vol. I, London, Oxford University Press, 1949, p.
297. If there were such taboos, plus elaborate ritual, and if miscarriage
was not tolerated, then abortion had no place.
7- The Mystique of Life, and Harmony in
African Religion
The foundation and purpose of the ethical perspective of Africa Religion
is life, life in its fullness. Everything is perceived with reference to
this. It is no wonder, then, Africans quickly draw ethical conclusions
about thoughts, words, and actions of human beings, or even of "natural"
cosmological events, by asking questions such as: Does the particular
happening promote life? If so, it is good, just, ethical, desirable,
divine. Or does it diminish life in any way? Then it is wrong, bad,
unethical, unjust, detestable. This most basic understanding of morality
in African Religion or tradition is incorporated systematically in
people's way of life. It is expressed in their traditions, ceremonies, and
rituals. It constitutes what Africans perceive as the mystique of life. (MAGESA,
L., African Religion: the Moral Traditions of Abundant Life, p.
77).
Similarly, for Africans harmony, as the
principle for moral order does not mean that people and other members of
creation lose their freedom. Harmony is the agent of freedom and is
meant to enhance it. But what does "freedom" mean? Does it imply license
or liberty to do whatever one wants? Such is not the case. In African
Religion or tradition, freedom is what enables a person to be fully who he
or she is. This applies equally to all beings: harmony (or freedom)
enables a tree to be fully a tree, a stone fully a stone, and a person
fully human. (MAGESA, L., African Religion: the Moral Traditions of
Abundant Life, p. 74).
Conclusion
With the above background, it is only natural to see why abortion has no
place in African Religion and traditional society. Admittedly, "Abortion
is an emotive issue -- cultural and religious values have always made it
taboo - until five years ago it was a criminal offence in this country.
And although the law may have changed, attitudes haven't," write Ruda
Landman and Kate Barry in their report, "DIY Abortion
Clinics," June 23, 2002. It is not surprising also that the nurses and the
majority of the medical staff, "want nothing to do with [Termination of
Pregnancy (TOP) or abortion], even if they're on duty in the ward." The biggest survey ever done amongst
doctors showed that more than 80% of South African doctors are against
abortion on demand. The government was fully aware of this attitude when
they forced the members of the African National Congress (ANC) to vote
against their consciences in support of "Termination of Pregnancy". They
should therefore not be surprised when only 5 of the 27 hospitals in
Mpumalanga have staff who are willing to take part in abortions.
At any rate, keeping in mind the Gospel
values, the Church's teaching, the Declaration of Human Rights, and the
rich religious-cultural background, the medical staff in any hospital,
clinic, health center or dispensary, must not be coerced against their
conscience to take part in abortion or contraception. Moreover,
considering all the suffering that many people endured during the dark
days of apartheid, the South African Government, and the people of South
Africa ought to be the first ones to oppose all the attitudes and
practices that are anti-life. Please, please, Africa has suffered enough,
let her children live!